Screen one field study
Identify building use, air-conditioning status, intervention and comparator. Flag uncertain eligibility with a cited passage rather than guessing.
Climate / building science
Planning / recruiting a research leadCompare measured indoor-air outcomes across roof types, weather and ventilation conditions. Find where the evidence is convincing and where it is thin.
Help shape this project ↗Draft protocol. No batches are running. No research partner or institutional endorsement is implied.
Reflective roofs are intended to reduce heat gain, but a cooler roof surface is not the same as a cooler occupied room. Field studies can use different sensors, buildings and comparison periods. The useful question is not just whether cooling occurs, but under which conditions and with what confidence.
Occupied residential buildings without mechanical air conditioning during measurement. Include field measurements with a stated comparator: a comparable untreated home or a documented before/after period. Separate coatings from insulation or ceiling changes. Keep laboratory experiments and simulation-only results outside the main evidence table.
Identify building use, air-conditioning status, intervention and comparator. Flag uncertain eligibility with a cited passage rather than guessing.
Record roof material and coating, insulation, ventilation, climate, season, sample size and sensor location. Extract indoor-air temperatures, measurement times and reported uncertainty.
Verify that a value is indoor air, not roof-surface or outdoor temperature. Distinguish peak reduction from daily mean, and matched comparisons from uncontrolled before/after observations.
Flag absent weather controls, short follow-up, unreported ventilation or combined interventions. Send contradictions and duplicate buildings to the project lead.
A building scientist and methods reviewer must approve the protocol. Begin with ten papers or all eligible papers if fewer. Use two independent extractions per comparison, verify every quantitative field and adjudicate disagreements. Record sensor accuracy, weather matching, building comparability and concurrent modifications.
Present comparable indoor-air measurements together, keeping peak and mean outcomes separate. Do not average surface temperature with indoor air or call an uncontrolled temperature change a causal effect. Pool results only after a researcher approves compatible definitions and a statistical method. An indoor-temperature finding is not proof of a health benefit.
A source-linked field-evidence table and a condition-by-condition map: roof construction, ventilation, climate and measurement method. Report missing information and weak comparisons alongside positive and null results.
Lead researcher not yet appointed. Protocol is a draft. A source may not establish whether every home was naturally ventilated; eligibility must be checked in the full text. Findings may be local, seasonal and affected by selection or confounding.
Starting literature
These sources motivate the question. They are not our findings, a complete search, or proof that every paper is eligible for reuse.
An empirical starting point. Its multiple roof technologies and controls illustrate why intervention details must be extracted separately.
A candidate methods source, not automatically eligible evidence. Separate field observations from modeled outcomes and verify access rights.